User 4869

Kudo wrong in AO episode 225. Heiji also wrong in mermaid case (222-224) and on his first appearance you mention. Kudo partly wrong is 472-473 but just because he's kid and the puzzle is not for him. Kodu also stumble a bit is his first and second case but fully save it in the end (162, 286-288) He also conceal the truth to protect people heart like Makoto-fake-Shinichi case in Araide first case 170-171

1. That's can't be help if you don't like that. I would not do better in her situation. Sacrifice one'self for other people I deem it good thing. Do you blame Kazuha for stab Heiji's hand? 2. I said she also protect Ayumi with her own body. and what time she hide behind Conan's back when no real danger involve. Subaru? he has BO scent and her BO scent prove correct. Ran also hide behind anyone for...Ghost. Atleast Haibara's fear is more tangible. 3. Conan point out that Ai don't used to people that care for other. Conan also point out that Ai is act strong but vulnerable inside so she don't know how to react to Ran for caring her for no reason. She don't want Ran to come because she don't know how to act around Ran. Not to mention that Ran remind her of her sister and she may fear that Ran could end up the same fate. You can use the incident after desperate revival as you argument that Haibara is jealous. But Conan said himself that if he tell Ran he love her she will even more sad because she will not see him. You even can interpret this scene as Ai care for Ran's heart. And let me ask you again. Is jealousy that bad? Ran once break random people door over her jealous for Shinichi. 4. Often Lab work would result in unexpected outcome. Sometime it create drug that useful to the world.(and presumably. That's her objective) This time it create poison and she can do nothing. She don't want it to be use and say it's one reason she resent the organization. You can see she feel bad on her drug. She went to Kudo house because it's her job. It's important to the plot that she must know Kudo turn small and she indirectly save his life when she confirm his death. Or esle it not make sense to send Lab people on field work anyway. 5. She slapped (actually hit) him only in Anime. In original Manga, Akemi appear before Conan,with disguise,with fake story. Do you watch "blue spark of hate." People get heart-attack, it's his bad luck. But the random passing by just let him die and result in he also get killed for revenge . Maybe it's not right to blame Conan but Conan it the only person who could save Akemi that time. And when Ai see Conan is very good. Would you feel a little bit regret. And she never act like that again. It only one moment that involve losing only person/relative you love. 6. It's for their own safety!!! I say only DB that boss Conan around. and Boss Agasa around. Sorry for Ran fan. I also like her very much "It take a lot of... to save people who about to shoot you" But I use Ran as argument because blueberry like Ran and hope he will see situation better.

He could just dump Ran and told nothing about his age to Ayumi, If he like her. Ai: If you break Yoshida-san's heart. I won't forgive you. Conan: Oi Oi.

Surprise to see a Ran fan create thread like this. Normally I would expect an Ai fan. This help me decide easily. I want Shinichi to be with Ran but I like Ai as a character more. So voted Ai

1 Second and third time she try to commit suicide. it's to keep Conan and DB save 2 And she step before Ayumi when a gunman threatening them. BTW Conan promise to look after her. 3 In that case, She look at Ran because she know Ran discover Conan's secret and plan to convince Ran otherwise. 4 She never intend to create poison. Pisco can confirm that. It has something to do with de-age or something. And Gin use that as poison without her approval. 5. Well. Isn't that true?. Akemi do that without telling Shiho. how can she do anything?. Conan is very bright he should see through that case. People sometime would blame thing on other people because they can't bear the burden alone. 6 It's for their own safety. And Haibara can't successfully force Conan to do that anyway OK. the point of the thread I don't like the Detective Boy. Bonus point for Genta for his passion for food and his voice. Bonus point for Ayumi for her voice also. Mitsuhiko is better than them. But the DB as a whole. 1 Think they are good, run into danger and fail to solve case every time (or is it almost). 2 Try to win over Conan and fail. Still think "The Detective Boy" is so awesome. Actually it's Conan who do most of the work. 3 Rude to Adult. Especially to Agasa and Takagi over their love life. Like they can do better. 4 For certain case.Two Mix. They ignore Conan command advice to hand traking glass to Megure. Try to locate kidnapper themselve so they can inform police themselve, get caugh, only difference between do as Conan told and do what they do is they will get credit. it did not effect the case in anyway, only put their life and Conan't life in danger. Only retailation they recieve is Conan say "Baka". Two Mix still try to defence them (When police scold them). Why Two mix think they are their savior and not their would-be murderer is beyond me. 5 Another certain case: Battle of the Haunted Warehouse's Treasure: after recive lecture about solve case themself and don't alway rely on Conan. They recruit Heiji to help them in case, Not for solving case but to defeat Conan so he will surrender. Completly miss the point. While Heiji and Conan himself would not accept credit if they didn't solve case themselve (Yuki no onna case). 6.Another case: The Old Blue Castle Investigation Case Genta behave nicest in this case. He just cilmb a fence into random house which he don't know the owner and would have get shot on particular situation. Ayumi ignore Haibara warning that she should ran away but went to "save" Haibara. It's not bad to help your new-found friend but how would she handle the threat that Conan, Agasa,Genta,Mitsuhiko,Haibra fall victim to. Isn't it better to ran and summon help? Mitsuhiko discover Conan's glass and went to save Conan himself without inform Ayumi and Haibara who's with him. that cound result it 1) he get cough, doomed the group fate. 2) Ayumi and/or Haibara get hurt while he's away. And to be fair Haibara: After fail to call for help once. Just let the matter drop and never try to call again. But actually I also wonder who she could call. If police don't buy her story. She has no relative and she probably don't know Mouri's number. Maybe she could call Gin "Hey, Gin, It's Sherry, could you pike me up here. I got into some mess. Conan: Discover secret passage. don't inform anyone, don't try to get out, just say "omoshiroi" (Interesting) and went to explore alone. get caugh first and result it the afromention situation. P.S. I could get banned for this.

Why FBI would concern Mouri family if his files not stolen yet Answer my own question: they saw picture in Vermouth's room and keep Conan and Ran in mind. Btw. Should we agree that he's not Araide first. that the point of the thread.

Akai appear in restaurant (V32) happen before Mouri file stolen (V33) So I say he's tailing Vermouth.

Oh. is that you? Chekhov. 1 You may want to add: Scar Akai carries umbrella with his right hand in his first meeting with Jodie. That mean he use right hand in both critical situation (fire a gun) and when it's not critical (carry umbrella). 2. Rebutting theory about Okiya Subaru is Kudo Yusaku. Some might suggest that Okiya Subaru is Kudo Yusaku since he use Holmes's quote about parent and child. But the fact is Conan talk about parent and child first and Subaru just rearrange it to fit Holmes's quote. 3. You may want to explored the possibility that Scar Akai is deaf so he didn't react to people around him. And this theory can rebutting with the fact that Jodie grab his arm. So there're no excuse about deaf

It's good that Aoyama didn't feel the pain same way as Conan or Ai or DC will end long ago. Haibara is given much of her character development especially in Vermouth arc. So her feeling is much explored. I'd say I will feel the same way as her in her situation (Suicidal, depress, feel like not belonged)

kudou has a girlfriend who supports him,kid's girlfriend detests him. Aoko like Kaito. She just Tsundere type A. It's true that Ran like Conan, Aoko hate Kid. kid hasn't got parents since small, kudou's parents were really helpful. No, especially the father. It had been years,and conan've got over 700 manga chapters,14movies, over 500 episodes and OVAs,kid only got 4 manga books. DC help popularize MK but Kid also the most favorite character among many DC fans kid's father-in-law hates him,kudou's father-in-law helps him(well,sort of after kudou turns small,conan uses mouri to deduce.) kid's father-in-law didn't punch him everyday. kid only got a peek at his girlfriend's panties,kudou got a look at everything. I say it's bad luck on Ran's side. kid often got threatened under guns,kudou only break a leg. The bomb in ep 304. also if not by chance, he died since Ep 1. kid has got no one support his magic tricks,kudou's got heiji to support his deductions. someone else covered this kid doesn't dare to yell his name,kudou calls himself a detective everyday. someone else covered this

Vote for Gin, Akai and Okiya here. If the latter two are the same person their vote will on par with Conan. But I guess it's cheating. LoL.

Yes Chris (Sorry I always call her Sharon so I misspell Chris) V.24 File. 9 P. 3 Age 29 Jodie Vol. 27 File. 7 P. 7 Age 28

The little Box under their face which write their name when they being introduce. Vermouth in 174 or 175 (She's 29)and Jodie in 226 (She's 28). Of Cause the Vermouth one was a lie. But I assume this is the age that is know to public. The one Christ give to media but actually she has Sharon's age which is at least 50 (You have to be 50 to have a 29 yeas old daughter). About Jodie is 4-5 at the time I assume by how she look.

Ok I didn't read all the way here. But will check later. I think both of them have something to do with war between Bo and FBI. Why? Okiya recognize Scar Akai and has reason to not being seen by him. He also don't want Jodie to reach the department store door. That make him "one of them" friend and Enemy for Bo, or for FBI. Scar Akai, if he's Akai, yes he's also involve. if he's not Akai himself. dress as Akai, put Mizunashi Rena in danger, Smile at Chainti, Gin has reason to not kill him after think he's Akai. that also make him involve in this matter. But they could be other beside Akai or Bourbon? I don't think so. When Gosho introduce Jodie as FBI. he's already has Jodie say the word FBI. also Akai friend also wear FBI jacket. In CIA case. they mention "Company" and CIA stock phase. If another third party will appear. there should be some hint toward them. Only FBI that missing is Akai. Only BO that missing is Bourbon. there no mention about anothe FBi or another BO. Since two people that involve in this matter appear. there likely that two. this is one of the problem for Akai = Subaru believer. I just say Time frame in DC world can't be take seriously. You remember Ran or Conan never move up their class (what's the correct word? I pretty mess up here but you got the Idea?). I.E. the incident involve Akemi Miyano is only "several month Ago" So we can't say "Okay one case past. that mean three day" or something. It was three case in manga between Akai dies and Subaru show up and two case between in the Anime. I won't say that "immediately" I think if you do thin on regular basis. and if you do that just 1 week. that observant kid would know. Remember. Conan react to Subaru address despite never went there. It's seem the two relate somehow.

Yes, there are possibility. but that possibility is very low. Since "Christ" only older than Jodie for 1 year. She don't suppose to kill Jodie while Jodie is 4-5 since she only 6 at the time. I didn't mean to be harsh. If that insult you I'm sorry. You absolutely can post you comment. But i just disgree with that comment. My posy also just an opinion. But movie is not canon is fact. So it can't reflect Auther in anyway.

I didn't ask "what" are their relation. I ask "why" he think they are what the are.

First you shouldn't use movie as reference because it's not canon. He keep appearing because he's popular, a fan favorite. Doesn't necessary connect to the main plot (didn't say they're not connected either).

Then who kill Jodie's father. Sharon kill and she happen to tell her daughter about that? and use her daughter fingerprint to touch Jodie' father glass without knowing it will survive the fire?

I already has reasons in mind. But could you please explain that why do you think they are Akai and Bourbon. Just share our opinion

The Boss is very cautious Picture Edit: The Anime (I don't know how to take screen cap) Vermouth also say our boss is cautious as hell.

Yes, Akai still misses Akemi . If he can't get over it .It will be useless to ask if he will going to end up with Haibara. But if he can get over Akemi. he'll go to next person available who I say is Jodie I think he serious about his relationship with Jodie. He took the time and effort to tell her they will break up. and "the person who love two woman at thee same time, that's not like me" It's tell us he love two woman but choose to date one. one of them is Akemi and other is Jodie so he love Jodie too

I try to answer Aka Peiji here 1. I doubt it would mislead us so much, - Mislead is a job of detectve story writer 2. especially with Haibara's reactions and his drinking of his namesake - Akai give her the feeling too 3. Also, as Kir said Bourbon was, Okiya is very intelligent, among other things - Conan is very intelligent. Heiji is . Yusaku is...well this guy more intelligent than the everyone. Just that not make them Bourbon. Okiya do some deduction battle with Conan so he's smart. Scar Akai send his deduction to Kogoro so he's also smart. Both are smart. who's Bourbon. 4. Bourbon is not under any disguise, as we see him constantly - We see Araide constantly and he's Vermouth at the same time . Vermouth also appear as herself, talking with Gin, send mail to Gin, throw a dart on Shiho's picture, and maitaine disguise as Araide 5. I doubt in many more ways than one that 'Scar Akai' is actually Bourbon. Besides them being in the same place at the same time in close proximity to one another - Scar Akai being in the same place with Okiya Subaru, none confirmed being Bourbon. None confirmed being Akai. You base your theory on Okiya=Bourbon. If Subaru not Bourbon, Scar Akai (who i Say- Bourbon)and Okiya(who I say- Akai) are difference people and absolutly can appear at the same place 6. and Bourbon seeming interested that Akai seemed to be alive - Just OKIYA seeming interested that some random guy appear as Akai 7. there's another issue with that -- wouldn't the Organization know that Bourbon was the scarred Akai if he came out of the building and not try to shoot him? he would let them know so he wouldn't be at suspect. - Bourbon is secretive. he don't tell BO what he going to do. He almost get shot and Vermouth arrive to tell the truth . Remember, when Scar Akai appear in front of department store. Gin has innner monologue "Akai Shuichi" then, Vermouth arrive and tell GIn something we do not hear and GIn call of the attact. 8. there's really no reason (if if to lure the real Shuu out) that a member of the Organization would stoop to disguising as someone they despise so much (especially Bourbon, whom was said to hate Shuu just as much). - He disguise to get reaction from Jodie, Camel and to lure real one out. Some guy name Makoto do a plastic surgery to be someone he hate the most before to get revenge on that specific person. In Scar Akai case, may be he's just wear a mask 9. On the point of them both smiling at the noticing of Chianti, I'm sure Bourbon wouldn't have waltzed out there in said 'disguise' of Scar Akai in plain sight, since I'm sure he would know the consequences. - what if Bourbon smile at chainti because he amuse that his disguise work out so well that fool not just FBI but BO too. about wondering around, he need to get of the store right. it's not in his plan that someone would see him on TV. He just want to appear before Jodie at the bank and then there's a robbery and he stuck and later appear on TV. If not a case come up. He will not appear on TV and BO won't notice them. By the time he's smiling. He probably notice Vermouth beside Gin car and know she will tell Gin who is he. 10. Away from that subject, yet still to Bourbon, I wouldn't be surprised if he already was highly suspect of Conan being Shinichi. It would seem that the fellow has quite the capabilities as a detective (probably the reason the BO chose him) and likely has figured out a lot just by seeing Conan work and being in Shinichi's home, noticing how everything's seemed to go missing and whatnot, among other things. It would be even less of a surprise if he put two and two together and exposed Sherry as Ai as well, even easier since he's right next door and can monitor much more easily. - You talking about Okiya, and If, my thoery is right, if Okiya is Akai. he's know already Sherry is Haibara. And probably know about Kudo too 11 By my reasoning and from what was said within the episode of when Gin and the others saw 'Scar Akai', I would believe that "that person" actually was the one that wanted operations to pause. As Vermouth said, even "that person" was nervous. Perhaps so nervous that s/he didn't want to test what would happen, so it was ordered that Kir be spared and the others to pull out.Though, of course, none of this can be proven until the information is finally released and the truth is exposed. - She said Anokata is very careful. it can interpret as "he double check whether Akai is alive or dead so he's have someone disguise as Akai to check it out"

Akai and Shiho look good together. The problem is Akai has another girlfriend beside Akemi who probably end up with him.

The point of have Ran kick Okiya in the face was to prove he's not wearing a mask. But Akai and Okiya face look similar anyway. One of the point made in the 13 redshirt case is that Both Scar Akai and Subaru is not Vermouth. and Scar Akai and Subaru are not the same person