ShinRanx3 0 Report post Posted June 11, 2012 We've got to remember that the movies are "ANIME ORIGINALS" Which means we can't be saying that her birthday is in May or April because of it, Gosho Aoyama has not actually told us when her birthday is yet... it's been like 2 months in the series [though years for us ] so we can't really expect her to have had her birthday yet Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Chekhov MacGuffin 1089 Report post Posted June 11, 2012 No precise date has been given for Ran's birthday, even in non-canon anime originals. I'm not sure where the October 1st date comes from, but I have yet to see any real justification for it. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
detective-db 16 Report post Posted June 11, 2012 I only know that her b-day is on October... 1 or 2 " Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Chekhov MacGuffin 1089 Report post Posted June 11, 2012 I only know that her b-day is on October... 1 or 2 " Like I said before, this is false info... Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Wakarimashita 137 Report post Posted June 12, 2012 We only know her birthday is 'a way off' from Eri's which is on october 10th. source : http://www.dctp.ws/V68-Reader/V68-2Read/A3.html That confirms that the '2nd of october' info is wrong, false, incorrect etc. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
theM 4 Report post Posted June 30, 2012 I know the source of Ran's October-birthday : At the beginning of one of first Live Actions (Dorama), Shinichi had said Ran's birthday was on the previous day, and on class the blackboard wrote, October 2nd. So according to the Dorama her birthday is October 1st. But I don't know how much influence Gosho has on the Dorama. Plus it makes not much sense as Ran said her birthday is 'a way off' from Eri's (October 10th) like Wakarimashita wrote. In Movie 1 Ran showed the horoscope of Taurus and said that her and Shinichi's lucky color this month is red. I know that the Movies are Anime-Originals BUT Gosho has influence on them as he often talks in interviews about the ideas he had e.g. for the 15th or 16th movie.But I don't know if this detail was Gosho's idea,too. Furthermore someone wanted to know Ran's blood type and I can say it's the same as Shinichi.(Volume 26) Most people say blood type B but I don't know the source for it. So they are same class,same blood type, maybe also same zodiac sign... Perhaps Gosho wants to show in this way that Ran and Shinichi are soulmates. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MadelineLime 45 Report post Posted August 12, 2012 I know the source of Ran's October-birthday : At the beginning of one of first Live Actions (Dorama), Shinichi had said Ran's birthday was on the previous day, and on class the blackboard wrote, October 2nd. So according to the Dorama her birthday is October 1st. But I don't know how much influence Gosho has on the Dorama. Plus it makes not much sense as Ran said her birthday is 'a way off' from Eri's (October 10th) like Wakarimashita wrote. In Movie 1 Ran showed the horoscope of Taurus and said that her and Shinichi's lucky color this month is red. I know that the Movies are Anime-Originals BUT Gosho has influence on them as he often talks in interviews about the ideas he had e.g. for the 15th or 16th movie.But I don't know if this detail was Gosho's idea,too. Furthermore someone wanted to know Ran's blood type and I can say it's the same as Shinichi.(Volume 26) Most people say blood type B but I don't know the source for it. So they are same class,same blood type, maybe also same zodiac sign... Perhaps Gosho wants to show in this way that Ran and Shinichi are soulmates. The live action is only canon to the live action. It has zero bearing on the manga, which is the main canon. Same thing with the movies. They are not canon. If it helps anyone to understand this, just think of them as fanfiction. Blood type has zilch to do with zodiac sign and being soulmates. You are born depending on when you were conceived. Also if you're going to go by astrology, only one or two signs actually get along with their own sign; usually they clash and just torment one another. A good relationship involves a balance of compromise and understanding, and strictly going by astrology, most signs are very particular on what they will or won't do, which makes a volatile mixture. Taurus (Shinichi's sign) with another Taurus is a weird mixture. Ran doesn't seem like a Taurus, though, but he certainly does. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
theM 4 Report post Posted August 16, 2012 The live action is only canon to the live action. It has zero bearing on the manga, which is the main canon. Same thing with the movies. They are not canon. If it helps anyone to understand this, just think of them as fanfiction. Blood type has zilch to do with zodiac sign and being soulmates. You are born depending on when you were conceived. Also if you're going to go by astrology, only one or two signs actually get along with their own sign; usually they clash and just torment one another. A good relationship involves a balance of compromise and understanding, and strictly going by astrology, most signs are very particular on what they will or won't do, which makes a volatile mixture. Taurus (Shinichi's sign) with another Taurus is a weird mixture. Ran doesn't seem like a Taurus, though, but he certainly does. You misunderstood me. I mean that Gosho probably wanted to use it as a stylistic device like: same favorite colour, same blood type, same age AND same zodiac sign => OH,so much in common,they seem to be soulmates! :-) Do you get it? Just like that - as a symbol. There's a high chance that it could be like that because the first three commonalities are official. The movies are not (exactly) Canon- still Gosho has influence on it. You see that Shinichi's birthday is in manga and in the movie 1 May 4th. So the birth information about Ran could be valid,too. Besides I know that the blood type and the zodiac sign are not connected and that being the same zodiac sign doesn't mean that you are soulmates. I'm into astrology for years and it's much more extensive than that. =) Relationship astrology is not just about your zodiac sign (Sun sign). Logically there could be another birth date for Ran. If you think about what Gosho said in one interview some months ago. He said that there is an obstacle why he can't reveal Ran's birthday yet and that Ran is still 16. Many fans think that something important will occur on her birthday. You can't really create a timeline from the story but we know that some months passed but not yet a year cause all students are still in the same class. Besides Gosho said that Conan will never grow meaning that if he would come in the next grade the story probably will be over. The japanese school year lasts formally till March 31st. So it could be that the finale occur in in the end of the school year. And as Ran's birthday is still left- there's a chance that it will occur at the end of the story (March supposable) like "Conan change forever into Shinichi as Ran's birthday present." I like the idea somehow. =D Though it's just a theory.^^ Wish you a nice day. :-) Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
...Infinity... 2 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 Ran' s Birthday , tho , is unknown , am eagerly waiting for it . Gosho Aoyama did confirm that when her birthday does come , it will be the key to many revelations . I am keen to know many things but I cannot really guess when her birthday actually DOES come . Just keen for the track to come Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
