premiumemo 37 Report post Posted October 23, 2013 Why gosho-sensei didn't make the Movies as the part of the Canon..? Don't you think it kinds of helps the storyline..? Like Haibara getting to get a little information on the Antidote... Or BO knowing Shiho is alive by hearing the call made to her sister's apartment phone..? It almost fits in the puzzle somewhat..! Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Coolroro 0 Report post Posted October 23, 2013 Well it is probably because he is not the writer of the movies and he doesn't have time with manga and anime which both in going The movie is with the story line because their writer was sure to make them like if gosho him self was who wrote them Sorry for the bad language the English isn't my first language Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MeitanteiSonoko 7 Report post Posted October 26, 2013 Aoyama-sensei adopting some little elements from non-canon stuff. But to make all of them canon will be a bad idea. A lot of non-canon things is idiotic (Remember those Conan's cameos in Magic Kaito Specials? Those are completely against the timeline) and a lot of them doesn't fit for many reasons. For example, Ai-san's calls... From Hakase's house... To her sister's phone. It's completely against the character and story (Ai-san didn't even wanted to involve Takagi-keiji, while in the movie she's almost telling Soshiki "Hey! I'm calling from Hakase! Come and get me!"). Same goes to Gin missed a silver knife clue. Gin... missed... It's way too hard to believe in that. But there IS a nice ideas in non-canon stuff. Occhan's story in The Fourteenth Target was brilliant and deserves to be canon IMO. But all in all, Aoyama-sensei have his own ideas about which way to take and he don't need to think about the other writers. It'll only make things harder. That's why I prefer movies to stay away from the main story. Raven Chaser was a wrong move IMO, even though I like Irish character very much. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
premiumemo 37 Report post Posted October 26, 2013 Aoyama-sensei adopting some little elements from non-canon stuff. But to make all of them canon will be a bad idea. A lot of non-canon things is idiotic (Remember those Conan's cameos in Magic Kaito Specials? Those are completely against the timeline) and a lot of them doesn't fit for many reasons. For example, Ai-san's calls... From Hakase's house... To her sister's phone. It's completely against the character and story (Ai-san didn't even wanted to involve Takagi-keiji, while in the movie she's almost telling Soshiki "Hey! I'm calling from Hakase! Come and get me!"). Same goes to Gin missed a silver knife clue. Gin... missed... It's way too hard to believe in that. But there IS a nice ideas in non-canon stuff. Occhan's story in The Fourteenth Target was brilliant and deserves to be canon IMO. But all in all, Aoyama-sensei have his own ideas about which way to take and he don't need to think about the other writers. It'll only make things harder. That's why I prefer movies to stay away from the main story. Raven Chaser was a wrong move IMO, even though I like Irish character very much. That was convincing... Thanks..! Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
