Jump to content
Detective Conan World
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Chekhov MacGuffin

Segregate or remove non-canon Black Organization members and info on the main BO page?

By Chekhov MacGuffin, in Wiki discussion

  

12 members have voted

  1. 1. Should non-canon Black Organization agents be listed alongside of manga canon Black Organization?

    • Yes, all the Black Organization members (including those only found in movies, Detective Conan Special, books, games, other sources) should be listed together
      2
    • No, manga canon BO should be listed separately from all non manga-canon BO
      10
    • Manga, anime, and movie canon Black Organization should be listed together, but separately from those only found in Conan Special, games, other sources
      0
    • Other. Please describe in comments.
      0

  2. 2. Should non-canon Black Organization be on a separate page altogether?

    • No, all BO can be listed on the same page (includes alongside the others or in their own section options)
      5
    • Yes, only manga-canon BO should be discussed on the main Black Organization page.
      6
    • Yes, Manga, anime, and movie canon Black Organization should be discussed on the main Black Organization page. All other BO only found in Conan Special, games, other sources should have their own non-canon page
      1

  3. 3. How is the Main Black Organization page most useful to you?

    • As an overview of everything BO related
      6
    • As a reference guide which helps you keep track of canon facts and build theories about the BO
      6
    • Other, Describe Below
      0

Recommended Posts

Chekhov MacGuffin    1089

Chekhov MacGuffin
Posted

Currently the Black Organization page lists multiple non-canon Black Organization members alongside the canon ones in the list of members, Organization structure diagram, and rankings. This includes movie-only BO, Conan Special BO, and BO from other Conan spinoffs.

 

The reason I think this issue is important right now is because the page is at a crossroad. The page is being pulled in two directions. One philosophy is that the page should be inclusive of all matters BO regardless of canon. The other side wants to carefully label and segregate manga-canon from not-manga canon to preserve the page as a reference because only the manga-canon information is useful to solving any of the ongoing mysteries in Detective Conan. The main page can't be both things and do both well.

 

Is the Black Organization page more useful to you as a reference for plot related topics which would benefit from segregation of manga-canon from non-manga-canon, or as a mixed overview of everything which doesn't benefit from segregation?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Go To Topic Listing
×
  • Create New...