Difference between revisions of "Oversights in Detective Conan"
m (cats) |
(DCTP back, mining my list) |
||
| Line 37: | Line 37: | ||
The corpse could have flopped over after impact, had postmortem spasms and turned over, or the coroner was incorrect about the instantaneity of the death. | The corpse could have flopped over after impact, had postmortem spasms and turned over, or the coroner was incorrect about the instantaneity of the death. | ||
{{clear}} | {{clear}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | === The Black Organization knows Akai's cellphone number === | ||
| + | In [[Clash of Red and Black]], how did Gin know Akai's cellphone number so that Kir could call Akai and tell him she wants the leave the Black Organization? If he didn't know it, then why did he expect Kir to know it? Keeping the same cellphone number from his Black Organization days would be a massive security risk. | ||
===Incorrect English in London=== | ===Incorrect English in London=== | ||
| Line 42: | Line 45: | ||
{{clear}} | {{clear}} | ||
| − | === Victim | + | === Victim starved to death without attempting to escape from the Red Wall locked room === |
In [[The Mansion of Death and the Red Wall]], the door to the room where Shusaku Akashi was barricaded in and the rolling trolley blocking the door were both undamaged. This would imply that Shusaku Akashi did not mount a serious attempt to escape by trying to break down the door or pick the lock. Normally it would be expected that a desperate starving person who had the energy to break a window to leave a dying message would attempt to escape imprisonment rather than docilely accepting death. | In [[The Mansion of Death and the Red Wall]], the door to the room where Shusaku Akashi was barricaded in and the rolling trolley blocking the door were both undamaged. This would imply that Shusaku Akashi did not mount a serious attempt to escape by trying to break down the door or pick the lock. Normally it would be expected that a desperate starving person who had the energy to break a window to leave a dying message would attempt to escape imprisonment rather than docilely accepting death. | ||
{{clear}} | {{clear}} | ||
| + | === Vermouth has Haibara's cellphone number === | ||
| + | In [[The Jet-Black Mystery Train]], how did Vermouth know Ai's cellphone number, so that she could text and threaten the shrunken scientist? | ||
| + | |||
| + | === Tooru Amuro's inconsistent information access === | ||
| + | In [[The Jet-Black Mystery Train]] and [[A Scarlet Return]], it seems incredibly arbitrary that [[Bourbon|Tooru Amuro]] has access to info like knowing that Gin found a [[Criminal Tracking Glasses|gum and wiretap]] [[Reunion with the Black Organization|combo]] [[Black Impact! The Moment the Black Organization Reaches Out|twice]], but doesn't get to see Akai's death files or his death video without permission. | ||
<!-- Please do not include examples below here --> | <!-- Please do not include examples below here --> | ||
Revision as of 19:08, 13 July 2015
This page lists what some fans believe to be oversights in Detective Conan: errors, plotholes, and omissions.
Because this is a contentious topic, please be civil and follow the format rules below. Also, please do not include oversights where the anime has done something differently from the manga or Gosho is consistently doing something unrealistically for dramatic effect. Those belong on the List of differences between the manga and anime and Internal rules in Detective Conan pages respectively.
This page uses a new and untried format, so rules and guidelines will be added as needed.
Contents
- 1 Format
- 2 List
- 2.1 Missed clue on the Roller Coaster
- 2.2 Gin right-handed in his first appearance
- 2.3 Dead victim flipped over
- 2.4 The Black Organization knows Akai's cellphone number
- 2.5 Incorrect English in London
- 2.6 Victim starved to death without attempting to escape from the Red Wall locked room
- 2.7 Vermouth has Haibara's cellphone number
- 2.8 Tooru Amuro's inconsistent information access
- 3 References
Format
==="Brief Description Here"===
In [[Mandatory link to case]] this thing happened that I think was wrong. A, B, and C is why I think so.
==== Rebuttals ====
If you have a difference of opinion or think you can resolve this error, this is where you put it.
{{clear}}
List
Missed clue on the Roller Coaster
In the Roller Coaster Murder Case, Shinichi mentioned that he felt a drop of liquid, the culprit's tear, hit his forehead as she leaned over him to place the loop around the victim's neck. However, Shinichi neglected to mention any change in the feeling or sound of the wind rushing past his face as the culprit leaned over him.
Gin right-handed in his first appearance
In the Roller Coaster Murder Case, Gin did everything like a right-handed person would. He adjusted his hat with his right hand and held the pipe he used to clobber Shinichi in his right hand. He also pulled the APTX pill out of the container and forced fed Shinichi the pill and the water with his right hand, only using his left as support. Gin was canonically confirmed to be left-handed later.
Dead victim flipped over
In An Idol's Locked Room Murder Case, the suicidal victim landed back-down on the knife and most likely died instantly according to the coroner[1], but the corpse is found in a belly-down position.
Rebuttal
The corpse could have flopped over after impact, had postmortem spasms and turned over, or the coroner was incorrect about the instantaneity of the death.
The Black Organization knows Akai's cellphone number
In Clash of Red and Black, how did Gin know Akai's cellphone number so that Kir could call Akai and tell him she wants the leave the Black Organization? If he didn't know it, then why did he expect Kir to know it? Keeping the same cellphone number from his Black Organization days would be a massive security risk.
Incorrect English in London
In Holmes' Revelation, the note written by Hades Sabara was grammatically incorrect and contained several misspellings.
Victim starved to death without attempting to escape from the Red Wall locked room
In The Mansion of Death and the Red Wall, the door to the room where Shusaku Akashi was barricaded in and the rolling trolley blocking the door were both undamaged. This would imply that Shusaku Akashi did not mount a serious attempt to escape by trying to break down the door or pick the lock. Normally it would be expected that a desperate starving person who had the energy to break a window to leave a dying message would attempt to escape imprisonment rather than docilely accepting death.
Vermouth has Haibara's cellphone number
In The Jet-Black Mystery Train, how did Vermouth know Ai's cellphone number, so that she could text and threaten the shrunken scientist?
Tooru Amuro's inconsistent information access
In The Jet-Black Mystery Train and A Scarlet Return, it seems incredibly arbitrary that Tooru Amuro has access to info like knowing that Gin found a gum and wiretap combo twice, but doesn't get to see Akai's death files or his death video without permission.
